Wüstenrot CR - Analysis of Building Savings in 4Q12


Language: English
Company: Wustenrot Stavebni Sporitelna
Provider: Helgi Analytics

This report analyses the building savings business in the Czech Republic for the 4Q2012. You will find all the necessary details regarding volume growth, market share, margin and asset quality development in the building savings (as well as mortgage lending segment). Also, the report compares profitability and efficiency ratio of the largest player CMSS with the main player in the mortgage lending business - Hypotecni Banka to find out how market dominance translates into economies of scale and superior profitability.

The key highlights from 4Q2012 we discuss in this report are:

• The business remains under pressure in spite of its impressive profitability. ROE fell to 15.2% in 2012 and net profit dropped 6% yoy in 4Q

• Lending continues to fall and is losing to mortgages. In 4Q12, the annual decline deepened to 3.3% yoy

• 4Q12 confirmed a recovery in terms of the number of new contracts sold, while deposits grew by a seasonally strong 3.2% qoq

• ČMSS remains the leader, but Raiffeisen grabs most of the growth

This report focuses specifically on development in Wüstenrot Stavební Spořitelna in 4Q2012. The main conclusions are: 

Market position

Similarly to Wüstenrot Hypoteční banka in mortgage lending, Wüstenrot Stavební Spořitelna is a relatively little bank, with a 10.5% share of lending and 8.7% of building savings deposits as of the end of 2012.

Although  the bank has been consistently building up its market position (and has gained 1-2% of the market in the last 6 years), it was the biggest loser on the loan market in 2012 (with market share falling by more than 50 bp), while the bank gained over 30 bp in deposits.

In 4Q, the bank lost 29 bp  in terms of its loan market share, but gained 8 bp in  its deposits market shareThe bank’s overall balance sheet momentum is mixed. One one hand, loan growth is being hammered by negative market development and Wüstenrot’s weakening market position (loan book  down 3.4% qoq and 7.9% yoy in 4Q). On the other hand, deposits increased  by a solid 2.5% qoq and 3.9% yoy in 4Q for exactly the opposite reasons.

Profitability

Partly because of its small size (and limited economies of scale and synergies with a would-be commercial bank on the Czech market) and its conservative approach (the bank has the best loan quality and provision coverage), the bank is traditionally  the least profitable building savings bank on the market. In 2012, the bank achieved ROE of “only” 9.7%, compared to the 15.2% of the 5-building savings banks average.

When adjusted for surplus of capital (when ROE is adjusted to the building savings market average for each bank), Wüstenrot is clearly the least profitable building savings bank on the market:

As shown in the report, the negative momentum in loan growth is taking its toll on the profitability of the sector. As it is the smallest building savings bank on the market (with relatively the highest cost base), no wonder Wüstenrot’s profitability is being doubly hit.

Asset quality

With non-performing loans at only 2.04% of the total and provision coverage of nearly 68% of non-performing loans, Wüstenrot Stavební Spořitelna is now the building savings bank with the best loan quality.

Thanks partly to the above, no wonder the need to create more provisions is low. In 2012, the bank created less than CZK 2 mil of new provisions, or 0.1% of average loans, by far the smallest amount in the sector.

Cost-efficiency

Size matters and the lack of economies of scale is reflected in Wüstenrot’s low cost efficiency. In 2012, the bank’s operating costs accounted for 1.27% of average assets, nearly twice as much as the other savings banks.

Cost savings and loan book development are the two main things to watch for at Wüstenrot in the coming quarters, in our view.

 

Banking | Czech Republic | May 29, 2013